Fact Sheet: Reforming Prior Authorization; Protect Patient Access to Timely Care
What is Prior Authorization?
Consumers with insurance coverage often need prior authorization from their health insurer or health plan before they can get a medical test or procedure, be admitted to the hospital, or secure a prescription drug or medical equipment.
Prior authorization is a decision by the health insurer or plan that a health care service, treatment plan, prescription drug, or durable medical equipment is medically necessary. Prior authorization was initially used by health insurers to minimize the overuse of expensive health care services.
Insurer Prior Authorization Delays and Denials are Increasing
For the past several years, providers and patients have continued to experience an increasing number of situations in which some insurers use the prior authorization process to deny payment for a service, or delay approval for a service. There are health insurers that now require physicians and other health care providers to secure prior authorization for routine tests, medications, and procedures that fall well within accepted standards of care, such as a test to identify Gastroesophageal reflux disease.
The delay of timely delivery of appropriate, medically necessary care is a critical problem for any patient, but especially for patients with chronic and complex conditions that require ongoing treatment and/or high-cost medications. If a patient has to get prior authorization continually, this process can hinder the patient's overall progress.
Inappropriate Prior Authorization Practices Lead to:
- Delays in patient care
- Significant administrative burden for providers, which detracts from patient care
- Increased health care costs for businesses, consumers, and government payors
Impact on Quality
- A study that measured the treatment, logistics, and cost of prior authorization at three rural oncology practices showed a median delay time of four days to start treatment3
- According to the survey by the American College of Cardiology (ACC), 77 percent of cardiology respondents reported that less time was spent on patient care due to the time required for medical documentation4
Prior Authorization Reforms Needed
HAP has joined other provider groups and consumer advocates in calling for legislation to reform prior authorization practices, highlighting that:
- Patient care should not be delayed based on administrative processes
- Health care providers should receive payment for delivering medically necessary services
- Health plans should make statistics about Pennsylvania approval and denial rates available on their websites
- The Pennsylvania Insurance Department has a role in evaluating, monitoring, and tracking health plan statistics related to approvals and denials in the state
National Movement to Improve Prior Authorization
HAP Supports House Bill 1194
HAP supports House Bill 1194, sponsored by Representative Steven Mentzer (R-Lancaster), to protect against inappropriate prior authorization practices. The bill amends Act 68 to implement common sense legislative protections against inappropriate payor practices, including:
- Downgrading inpatient admissions to “observation” status thereby underpaying hospitals for medically necessary services for patients
- Denying payment for medically necessary services based solely on administrative errors on the claim, with limited or no process to remedy the errors
- Denying a claim after prior authorization was obtained based on information that was not available at the time of obtaining the prior authorization
- Denying a claim for a service which is medically necessary, but was not pre-authorized, as it was identified during the course of treating the patient for an authorized service
- Failure to communicate reasons for denials, which limit providers’ ability to appeal
- Failure to indicate a service is an uncovered service and will result in non-payment
- Failure to update online tools which are required for patient eligibility in a timely fashion
- Failure to provide timely determinations, especially after hours and during weekends
AMA Prior Authorization (PA) Physician Survey Results7
- For those patients whose treatment requires PA, 91 percent report delayed access to necessary care
- 28 percent reported PA led to a serious adverse event (e.g., death, hospitalization, disability/permanent bodily damage, or other life-threatening event)
- 75 percent report that PA can lead to patients abandoning their course of treatment
- 88 percent report PA burdens have increased over the last five years
- More than 1 in 3 (36%) of physicians have staff who work exclusively on PA
- An overwhelming majority (85%) of physicians report that PA interferes with continuity of care
HAP urges Pennsylvania lawmakers to pass House Bill 1194, to remove administrative barriers that delay patient access to care and services, burden providers, and result in hospital underpayments.
1 Morley CP, Badolato D, Hickner J, Epling JW. The Impact of Prior Authorization Requirements on Primary Care Physicians' Offices: Report of Two Parallel Network Studies. Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine. (January-February 2013). Vol. 26, pp. 93-95.
2 Brown GC and Brown M. Preauthorization. Current Ophthalmology Reports. Volume 6, Issue 3. Sept. 2018.
3 Agarwal A, Freedman RA, Goicuria F, et al. Prior Authorization for Medications in a Breast Oncology Practice: Navigation of a Complex Process. Journal of Oncology Practice 2017 13:4, e273-e282.
4 Barriers to New Medications for Cardiovascular Disease: Insights from CardioSurve. American College of Cardiology. Cardiology Magazine. February 23, 2017.
5 2018 Prior Authorization State Law Chart. American Medical Association Advocacy Resource Center.
6 Consensus Statement on Improving the Prior Authorization Process. Published by the American Medical Association, American Hospital Association, America’s Health Insurance Plans, American Pharmacists Association, BlueCross BlueShield Association, and Medical Group Management Association. January 17, 2018.
7 2018 AMA Prior Authorization (PA) Physician Survey. American Medical Association. February 2019.
Topics: Access to Care, Health Care Reform, Insurance, Regulatory Advocacy, State Advocacy
Revision Date: 6/1/2019
Return to Previous Page